• “But in the end, stories are about one person saying to another: This is the way it feels to me. Can you understand what I’m saying? Does it feel this way to you?”

    — Kazuo Ishiguro

    My name is Ely, and I have been collecting stories all my life.

    Thank you for reading.

  • On Doubting Thomas

    (John 20:24-29)

    As I was gathering text for an upcoming piece, I realized that in order to choose the text, I had to wrestle with it first. Over the course of my church-going years, this story has always been used as a way to lightly scorn the doubters. Such a heavy focus is placed on Jesus’ gentle admonishment in the final verses, as well as his statement of “blessed are those who have not seen, and yet believed”: a seemingly exclusionary proclamation. This final statement is then used to stroke the ego of the modern Christian, who doesn’t have the good fortune of living in the era when Jesus walked the earth and therefore has no choice but to believe without seeing. Therefore, rejoice, because we are blessed! We aren’t like Thomas; we’ve had to rough it out without the physical presence of Christ incarnate, and that means our faith is all the more strong for it. Meanwhile Thomas, that unfortunate skeptic, is labelled an object lesson and placed back on the shelf until he becomes a convenient example of a ‘bad Christian’ yet again.

    So, what to do with Jesus’ rebuke and blessing? Are we to assume that because Thomas couldn’t believe without seeing, he was not blessed? How are we supposed to take Jesus’ final words if not as a delineation between the faithful and the failing?

    I don’t have the answer to any of these questions, and no doubt many a wiser individual than me has attempted them already. I would rather do away with trying to answer these questions at all, and focus on something else; an element of this story that, I believe, demonstrates more about the implicit character of God than any haggling over who is blessed and who is not.

    That element is this: God shows up. God gives Thomas exactly what he asks for.

    Like Gideon in the desert, Thomas is not so easily taken in; he is a practical man, a facts man. He refuses to believe the word of his friends, who are no doubt grief-stricken and desperately searching for any shred of possibility that Jesus is what he said he was. Thomas is trying to move on.

    So he demands proof. And God shows up.

    Jesus appears in that room with locked doors not for the ten that already believe, but for the one that can’t. The others have already seen and believed; is it not fair that Thomas also get his turn? He offers Thomas everything he asked for: the wounds in his hands, the hole in his side. This is presented without judgement and simply followed with the command of “believe”, which Thomas unflinchingly obeys.

    Then He said to Thomas, “Reach your finger here, and look at My hands; and reach your hand here, and put it into My side. Do not be unbelieving, but believing.”
    28 And Thomas answered and said to Him, “My Lord and my God!”

    John 20: 27-28 (NKJV)

    Is this a story of human frailty? Perhaps. But is it more moreover a story of God allowing us to be what we are––human, body, flesh, tactile, seeing––and meeting us in that place of physicality? Is this not the bread and wine offered up once more?

    In the end, Thomas simply receives the same “proof” that the other disciples had already gotten. He did not doubt God, but his companions’ powers of perception. And who wouldn’t? Anyone who wanted the impossible to be true––for their Savior to be alive against all odds––couldn’t risk it all on hearsay. This would be too important, too potentially life-shattering to believe without proof. Jesus understood this, and that is why he appears: for the one who cannot believe, for the sheep still outside the pasture––the one who waits until he knows it is his Master’s voice calling, and not a stranger. 

    – Originally written May 21, 2021

  • The Winter of Our Discontent

    This is the original draft of an article published in the Winter 2022 edition of The Forum, a student publication of Hillsdale College. That article, intended to be a media analysis of the Netflix show Daredevil, can be found here. This version of the essay is a much more personal take on the experience of doubt in the Christian life.

    The Holy Week of my freshman year coincided with my first foray into the liturgical church. A baby evangelical at best, fresh off a series of encounters with a family friend recently converted to Catholicism, I was seeking something a bit deeper than the trite “concert and pep talk” formula of my youth. For a short period in my life, the Anglican church provided that. On this particular Friday night the sanctuary was bare and stark, yellow light splashed across the walls from dozens of candles clutched in reverent hands. We had just listened to what felt like hours of scripture and prayer, proceeding with a grim finality towards the Savior’s death and burial. Now, all I could hear was the creak of pews and kneelers, the feather-light breaths of those sitting to my left and right. It was quiet in the only way humans can be quiet while they are awake: with anticipation and unease. 

    Then, a shout in the dark: “He is risen!” and a cacophony erupted from the choir loft as every light in the building burst into life in one single, grandiose gesture. The euphoria of that moment clung to me for days afterward. It felt as though whatever I had felt or believed about the resurrection before had finally become real. 

    Ironic then, that barely a year later I would end up unaffiliated with any denomination, having not attended the Anglican church in an equal amount of time. Whatever I had experienced during that one holy night was quickly overshadowed by what I saw as an insurmountable hurdle: the silence of God. For context, my religious background before college emphasized a heavily emotional element to one’s faith. The role of a ‘prayer warrior’ was a pillar within my church culture, with the underlying assumption that everyone was––or at least should be––connected with God on an intimate and personal level, all day, all the time. Meanwhile, doubt was the work of Satan, trying to turn God’s servants away from Him. Not only did this make for a difficult environment in which to ask questions, but it also put the onus completely on the individual to sustain themselves in their faith.

    Of course, this struggle is nothing new: thousands of years ago, Job demanded to know why God remains absent in the face of the prosperity of the wicked. In 1959, Mother Theresa wrote about a “terrible pain of loss” within her soul: ”of God not wanting me, of God not being God, of God not really existing”. As Shusaku Endo describes the plight of monks in 17th century Japan: “The black soil…has been filled with the lament of so many Chrisians; the red blood of priests has flowed profusely; the walls of churches have fallen down; and in the face of this terrible and merciless sacrifice offered up to Him, God has remained silent.” 

    My circumstances were not nearly so dramatic, of course; I was no martyr, no saint, no lifelong servant of God. I was a confused and disillusioned teenager, sullen at being denied the one thing everyone around me seemed to have already achieved: emotional intimacy with the Savior. I had expected the high church liturgy to amend this, somehow. And when it didn’t, I grew bitter. 

    I decided that God and I must be at a stalemate. I refused to be the first to break the silence (that would be giving in), and so spent my sophomore and junior years in a haze of skepticism and, more often than not, grief. I attended church occasionally, but only when invited. The idea of sitting in a pew, surrounded and yet entirely alone, numbly observing the ancient rituals that at one point meant everything but now felt like a petty compensation, was more than I could bear. 

    In season 3 of Marvel’s Daredevil, Matt Murdock wallows in the midst of this same despair. Injured to the point of immobility by an explosion, he holes up in the basement of his childhood church, refusing Father Lantom’s offers of the Eucharist. His hearing is damaged, making it near-impossible for him to walk now that he is both blind and mostly deaf. To him, this means that God has finally shown his ‘true face’. Matthew spent years faithfully protecting Hell’s Kitchen, only to have his role as Daredevil be violently stripped from him. He compares himself to Job, God’s faithful servant who did everything He asked, only to be tormented and nearly destroyed without reason. And still, Job would not curse his Creator. To this, Matthew says, “Job was a coward.” As a child, he had believed that his uncanny ability to hear the whispered prayers of people in church was some kind of spiritual gift. “I thought it was God’s voice,” he tells Father Lantom. “But I was wrong. All I ever heard was people in pain. And all He ever gave any of us was silence.” 

    The days of Moses on Mount Sinai are long past. It is a rare Christian who can attest to wrestling with an angel on a mountain, or receiving visions of the second coming. Many of us are simply fumbling through life, sometimes aided but more often baffled by an ancient text that, we are told, possesses the answers to life and the universe. To make matters worse, our lived reality often conflicts with theological principles. Reconciling the truths about God that we learned as children with the truths of our own circumstances, or the circumstances of those around us, becomes a near-impossible task. What to do, then, when God won’t answer his calls?

    Our natural response is to grieve. 

    In Daredevil, Matthew never receives any kind of supernatural sign that his path is the correct one. Instead, he is faced with a series of decisions: to resent or forgive his mother for abandoning him, to push away or reconcile with his friends, to take a life or allow the justice system to enact its own punishment, despite having failed before. It is through these choices that he learns who he is, and who God is. As Matthew tells his mother in the final moments of the show, “if my life had turned out any differently, I would never have become Daredevil. Maybe it is all part of God’s plan. Maybe my life has been exactly as it had to be.” 

    For myself, I couldn’t describe when or how I found my way back from that horrible place of cynicism. I could point to certain events that maybe influenced it––a conversation with my roommate, the collapse of my church back in California during the lockdown of 2020––but those hardly amount to any particular moment of epiphany. What saved me was the repetition of a singular choice: to keep believing in all of it, even when I didn’t have a good reason to. There was a kind of desperation to it, at first; if I gave up my faith in God, what would I have left? If someone had asked me why I was a Christian back then, I probably would have answered with something along the lines of “because I don’t know what else to be.” I didn’t want to try to understand a world without a God in it, because I was terrified of what I might see. 

    My faith is not just a preventive measure against insanity or hopelessness, but is an active thing, a framework by which I understand and perceive the world. I am no more certain or uncertain of doctrine than I was four years ago, truth be told. I still have no church affiliation, and my prayer life is tenuous at best. I can confidently say that I believe God exists and that he is Good, but beyond that I am more or less drifting on a proverbial lifeboat of tradition. The difference is that now I don’t hate myself for it. As for the silence that I resented so much, that is still present. But it is more like two people sitting comfortably in the same room, quiet in the intimacy of understanding without needing to speak aloud. 

    From my experience, there doesn’t seem to be any encompassing theological explanation for why Christians experience such a deep and profound separation from God. Despite this, people are quick to hand out solutions: “Pray more.” “Get rid of sin in your life.” “Have faith.” However, when one is already following these prescribed steps of Christian life to the best of their ability, these solutions have no merit. They’re more akin to prosperity gospel than anything else, a kind of insidious victim-blaming: if the believer is suffering spiritually, it is because they must have some unconfessed sin or are simply not trying hard enough. Turning God’s relationship with his children into a meritocracy is disingenuous at best, and permanently damaging at worst. 

    As we approach this bitter season, as the days end foreshortened and the sun grows distant and confused, let us remember that silence is not merely an absence of song or sound. Silence is preparation. It is a held breath and suspended hands, the hush of an auditorium as the lights dim: a deliberate space where nothing is heard but everything that follows will be given weight.

    Hold onto the silence, my friends. There is music on the other side.

  • The Innocence of Low Art

    This essay was originally published in the Fall 2021 edition of The Forum, a student publication of Hillsdale College.

    There are two wolves inside of you. One listens to Górecki’s third symphony on repeat, spellbound by the peculiar timbre of the female vocalist and the soaring melody line underpinned by brooding strings. The other is content with a massive K-pop playlist, curated over five years of avidly following the genre. Which wolf will devour the other? 

    So not everyone has one hundred and six hours of K-pop saved to their Spotify library. That might be a personal problem. But it illustrates the questions I’ve been asking myself for the last four years: can one still profess to be invested in high art if they are equally tied to low art? And does the interest in the latter come at the price of understanding the former?

    K-pop, our titular example of ‘low art’, is uncomplicated, unsophisticated, and increasingly focused on catchy soundbites and listenability. It combines the addictiveness of the American pop industry with the most breathtakingly efficient elements of South Korean work culture. The common perception of those unfamiliar to the genre that “they all look alike” has some grain of truth to it, own-race bias aside. Most entertainment companies seek out young people who fit the metric for conventional attractiveness. And of course, they all sing, they all dance, they all look charismatic on camera. The individual is as much a production project as the music they perform.

    This is the genre I have chosen to stake my flag in: music at its most capitalistic, packaged, and digestible, the Raisin Bran of performing arts. Thus, it begs the question: shouldn’t I know better by now? Shouldn’t I have shed the last vestiges of pop music after experiencing George Crumb’s Makrokosmos my freshman year? Have I not been changed?

    Of course I have. No one experiences high art with any fraction of curiosity and goes unaltered. I have a fair amount of curiosity and my education has thoroughly steeped me in the great works. And after all this percolation, I would still argue that we need low art just as much as we need high art. Indeed, to ignore or dismiss low art is to separate oneself from a vast portion of the human experience. This is especially true when taste is equated to morality or intelligence. Not only are you distancing yourself from your fellow man, but you are standing over him and claiming a false divide because you listen to Bartok while he listens to Beyonce (a truly grotesque fallacy). 

    What purpose, then, does low art serve? In order to answer this question, we must first define high art and its purpose. While ‘high’ necessarily implies a hierarchy, it is also a helpful summary in that high art exists to point us to higher things, things that lie just beyond the realm of our experience. To quote Hillsdale’s favorite philosopher, it is that “stretching out to know” that characterizes the human response toward high art. We reach out to touch infinity, but are left with the lingering sensation of brushing hands.

    Meanwhile, ‘low’ art exists at our eye-level. It is easier to comprehend, and can often be immediately understood without further analysis. Low art is instant gratification for the soul, a slideshow of aesthetically pleasing stimuli intended for entertainment rather than introspection. In general, low art seems to provide no benefit to the soul beyond a surface-level pleasure. As a result, many would deem it useless at best, and detrimental at worst. And if we claim to believe the aforementioned beloved philosopher, then all things that do not benefit the soul must be jettisoned. (No K-pop allowed at my good Christian school.)

    While I can tolerate Aristotle, I adore pop music. And while I am completely open to the idea of something being amiss within my soul, that answer seems too easy. It also doesn’t account for the aesthetic experience of most of humanity. Most people don’t have the privilege of attending a liberal arts school so they can be told what good taste looks like. 

    In his book The Sacred Space of Music, Roger Scruton describes music as possessing a certain intention. This intention lies outside the influence of the composer and out of reach of the performer; it exists within music just by virtue of it being music. Human beings recognize this intention through the perception of movement. This, however, is paradoxical. Nothing in music technically moves. “C is stuck forever at C”, Scruton writes. Yet we say that melodies move, that harmonies shift, that chords have progression and movements have closure. So said Galileo, e pur si muove. This is a universal attribute of music, high or low or in between. It is this element of music that connects it to the human experience.

    The phenomenon of low art, though less complex than its elevated counterpart, is no less wondrous. It is a necessary expression of human function. Whenever we enjoy a piece of music, we are responding to its intention. We dance, clap, nod our heads, tap our feet all in a sympathetic motion, a moving with. “The life in the music is there by virtue of the fact that you can dance with it. . . the life in music is an imagined life, and the dance one way of imagining it.”   I find myself engaged with my own humanity when I listen to pop music just as I do when I listen to classical––perhaps even more so. After spending hours in an intellectual ivory tower, the humility of simple chords and singable melodies becomes profound. I once witnessed an entire stadium sing in a language most of them didn’t speak. Were they responding to the people on the stage, a childish exchange of gestures like an infant learning how to smile? Maybe so. But when those performers stepped back, put their microphones down, and listened, the singing went on. How many of us knew what we were saying? Did it matter? Or was the point of it all that we had witnessed an intention within the music that none of us could control, but we were all responding to? And in that moment, could anything be more divine?

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free